Why is my engagement rate dropping?

Why is my engagement rate dropping? Graphic of smartphone with emojis next to it.

1. Your content has become repetitive

Even loyal followers can lose interest if your content starts to feel too predictable. If you’re posting the same type of photo, video or caption over and over, people might scroll past without interacting.

  • Experiment with new formats (e.g. Reels, carousels, voiceovers)
  • Ask questions in captions to spark interaction
  • Share more behind-the-scenes or personal content

2. The algorithm has shifted

Social media platforms tweak their algorithms constantly. What worked a few months ago might not work today. For instance, Instagram may suddenly favour Reels over static posts, or prioritise saves and shares over likes.

  • Stay updated on platform trends and changes
  • Test different types of content and see what performs best
  • Prioritise content that encourages longer watch times or saves

3. You’re posting at the wrong times

If your audience isn’t online when you post, your content might get buried before anyone sees it. Timing plays a bigger role than many people realise.

  • Check your analytics to see when your audience is most active
  • Schedule posts for peak times (this might vary between weekdays and weekends)

4. You’re not engaging enough yourself

Social media is a two-way street. If you’re not replying to comments, commenting on other people’s posts or interacting with your audience, engagement can slow down over time.

  • Spend 10–15 minutes engaging with your community before and after you post
  • Reply to comments and DMs regularly
  • Show up in Stories with polls or questions to invite conversation

5. You’ve attracted passive or irrelevant followers

Sometimes growth comes at the cost of quality. If you’ve grown quickly through giveaways, viral content or follow-for-follow strategies, some of your audience might not be truly interested in your niche.

  • Focus on creating value for your core audience
  • Avoid engagement pods or spammy growth tactics
  • Consider removing ghost followers if necessary

6. People’s online behaviour has changed

Seasons, holidays, exam periods, or global events can all affect how much people engage online. If your followers are distracted or taking breaks from social media, engagement naturally dips.

  • Don’t take it personally—ride out the slow periods
  • Use the downtime to experiment and plan future content
  • Stay consistent, even when numbers are low

7. You haven’t analysed your content recently

Sometimes a little self-review goes a long way. If you haven’t looked at your analytics in a while, you might be missing important patterns.

  • Review your top-performing posts and see what they have in common
  • Track your engagement rate monthly to spot trends
  • Use insights to guide your content strategy

Engagement drops happen to every creator at some point. The key is to stay curious, not discouraged. Analyse, experiment, and reconnect with your audience—and you’ll likely see those numbers climb again.

PUSH.fm sign up for free GIF
Found this helpful? Share it with your friends!
Close Bitnami banner
Bitnami